Holiday Fraud Prevention: 7 Tips to Protect Your Money This Season

cropped shot of young couple shopping online with credit card and laptop at christmas

Unfortunately, holiday shopping scams and other types of financial fraud can take advantage of the extra activity this time of year. Fake delivery notifications, too-good-to-be-true deals, and messages pretending to come from trusted organizations can put your personal information and money at risk.

The good news? You don’t need to be a fraud expert to take steps to protect yourself.

At Finger Lakes Credit Union, we’re here to help you feel confident about your finances through every season. With a few simple habits, you can help protect your money, spot common holiday scams, and spend more time enjoying what makes this time of year special.

1. Shop Online Safely and Watch for Holiday Shopping Scams

That unbelievable sale on the gift you’ve been searching for might seem like a holiday miracle. But before you enter your payment information, take a moment to make sure the deal is legitimate.

Scammers often create fake shopping websites, social media ads, and online stores that look like the real thing. Their goal is to get you to pay for something that never arrives or share information they can use to commit fraud.

How to protect yourself when holiday shopping online:

  • Shop with retailers you know and double-check website addresses before making a purchase.
  • Be cautious of prices that seem unusually low or offers that pressure you to buy immediately.
  • Avoid clicking shopping links in unexpected emails or text messages. Visit the retailer’s official website instead.
  • Use secure payment methods and review the fraud protections available to you.
  • Keep receipts and order confirmations so you can compare them with your account activity.

A few extra seconds of checking can help you avoid a costly mistake and keep your holiday budget on track.

2. Don’t Fall for Fake Package Delivery Texts

Waiting for a gift to arrive? You’re not alone. That makes the holiday season a convenient time for scammers to send fake delivery notifications.

You might receive a text claiming your package is delayed, your address needs to be confirmed, or a small redelivery fee is required. The message may include a link that takes you to a fake website designed to collect your personal or payment information.

Before clicking, ask yourself: Was I expecting this message, and can I verify it independently?

Here’s what to do:

  • Track packages through the retailer’s website or the shipping carrier’s official app.
  • Don’t click unexpected links asking for payment or personal information.
  • Be cautious of messages that threaten to return or cancel a package unless you act immediately.
  • If you aren’t sure a message is legitimate, contact the company using information from its official website.

Remember, a familiar logo or convincing message doesn’t guarantee that a notification is real. When in doubt, go straight to the source.

3. Recognize Phishing Emails, Texts, and Phone Calls

Imagine receiving a message that says your bank account has been locked or a suspicious transaction needs your immediate attention. It’s natural to want to fix the problem right away.

That’s exactly what scammers are counting on.

Phishing scams use fake emails, texts, and websites to trick people into sharing sensitive information. Scammers may also spoof caller ID to make a phone call appear to come from a legitimate business or financial institution.

Be cautious if someone unexpectedly asks you to:

  • Share your online banking password, PIN, or one-time security code.
  • Click a link to resolve an urgent account issue.
  • Provide your debit card number or other sensitive information.
  • Move money to a supposedly safer account.
  • Pay through gift cards, cryptocurrency, or an unusual payment method.

Here’s an important reminder from Finger Lakes Credit Union: We will never email you asking you to confirm sensitive details such as your account number, debit card information, online banking code, or PIN.

If a message claims to be from Finger Lakes Credit Union and something doesn’t feel right, don’t respond or click its links. Contact us directly using the information on our Security Center.

4. Monitor Your Bank Account and Set Up Purchase Alerts

Holiday spending can add up quickly. Between gifts, groceries, travel, and celebrations, it can be easy to overlook a transaction or two.

That’s why checking your account activity regularly is one of the simplest ways to help protect your money.

Make account monitoring part of your routine throughout the season:

  • Review recent transactions and look for purchases you don’t recognize.
  • Check your account after busy shopping days.
  • Use available card or transaction alerts to stay informed about purchases.
  • Keep your banking passwords strong and unique and enable multifactor authentication when available.
  • Contact your financial institution promptly if you spot something suspicious.

Finger Lakes Credit Union members can also explore Visa Purchase Alerts, an opt-in service that can send notifications about qualifying card transactions based on the alert settings you choose.

These alerts can help you stay informed about your spending and recognize potentially suspicious activity sooner.

5. Watch Out for Charity Scams and Gift Card Fraud

The holidays are a time when many of us look for ways to give back. Whether you’re donating to a local cause, helping a family in need, or purchasing gifts for loved ones, it’s important to make sure your generosity reaches the right people.

Unfortunately, scammers sometimes pose as charities, create fake donation campaigns, or impersonate someone who needs urgent financial help.

Before donating or sending money:

  • Research charities independently and use their official donation channels.
  • Be wary of unexpected requests that pressure you to give immediately.
  • Verify requests for help by contacting the person or organization through a trusted channel.
  • Never pay an unexpected bill or supposed fee using gift cards.
  • Be cautious of requests to send money through cryptocurrency, wire transfers, or payment apps to someone you don’t know.

If someone claims to be a family member or friend asks for emergency financial help, take a moment to verify the situation. A quick call to another trusted person can help you avoid a scam.

Your generosity matters. Taking time to verify a request helps you make sure your gift goes where you intended.

6. Protect Your Money While Traveling for the Holidays

Heading out of town to visit loved ones or enjoy a holiday getaway? Traveling often means using your cards in unfamiliar places, connecting to public Wi-Fi, and checking accounts on the go.

A little preparation can help you keep your financial information safer while you’re away.

  • Keep your wallet, debit cards, and phone secure, especially in crowded public places.
  • Avoid accessing financial accounts over unsecured public Wi-Fi.
  • Use strong passwords and keep your phone and banking apps updated.
  • Check account activity during your trip.
  • Know how to report a lost or stolen card quickly.

If you’re using your Finger Lakes Credit Union card while traveling, you can find helpful information about debit card features and card security on our website.

Taking these precautions can help you focus on making memories instead of worrying about your money.

7. Know What to Do If You Suspect Fraud

Even when you’re careful, scams can happen. If you notice an unfamiliar charge, click a suspicious link, or believe someone has accessed your personal information, don’t panic. Focus on taking the next right step.

If you suspect fraud, here’s what to do:

  1. Contact your financial institution promptly. Report suspicious transactions or communications and ask what steps you should take to protect your account.
  2. Secure affected cards and accounts. If available, lock your card and follow your financial institution’s instructions for replacing it or preventing additional unauthorized transactions.
  3. Change compromised passwords. Start with your financial accounts and email, especially if you’ve reused the same password elsewhere.
  4. Save relevant details. Keep suspicious texts, emails, transaction records, and other information that could help with an investigation.

If you believe you’ve been targeted by a scam or attempted fraud involving Finger Lakes Credit Union, call us at 315-781-1334 or 855-866-9328. You can also visit our Security Center for additional guidance.

You don’t have to figure it out alone. Reaching out quickly can help you understand your options and take steps to protect your finances.

Enjoy a Safer, More Confident Holiday Season

The holidays are about more than shopping lists and packed schedules. They’re about spending time with the people you care about, creating meaningful memories, and looking forward to what’s possible.

Protecting your money is part of protecting those moments.

By recognizing holiday shopping scams, being cautious with unexpected messages, monitoring your accounts, and verifying requests before sending money, you can take practical steps to help keep your finances safer this season.

At Finger Lakes Credit Union, we’re proud to be a financial partner you can count on through every season of life. If you have questions or something doesn’t seem right, we’re here to help you find the next step.

From all of us at Finger Lakes Credit Union, we wish you a safe, happy, and memorable holiday season!

About the Author

Meghan Rodgers

Meghan Rodgers  

Assistant Vice President & Geneva Branch Manager

Meghan Rodgers serves as Assistant Vice President and Branch Manager of the Geneva Office at Finger Lakes Credit Union. In this role, she leads her team with a strong focus on member relationships, operational excellence, and delivering the personalized service that defines the Credit Union experience.

As Branch Manager, Meghan is dedicated to creating a welcoming environment where members feel supported in achieving their financial goals. She works closely with her team to ensure every interaction reflects the Credit Union’s commitment to service, trust, and community. Her leadership emphasizes collaboration, accountability, and empowering staff to provide knowledgeable, solution-focused support to every member who walks through the door.

Meghan’s approach to leadership is rooted in building meaningful connections both within her team and throughout the Geneva community. Through her guidance, the Geneva Office continues to strengthen relationships with members while upholding the values and service standards that define Finger Lakes Credit Union.